Opinion: WeHo Has a Choice to Make If It Really Wants to Welcome People of All Races

You don’t have to live in West Hollywood to care about who is representing and running the city.

West Hollywood made a name for itself by being a safe haven for the (white) LGBTQ+ community.  But the city isn’t just near and dear to the 70% of white people who call West Hollywood home.  For the millions of others who visit from near and far to experience the gay center of Los Angeles, West Hollywood is seen as a refuge and an identifiable safe space where they know they can be accepted in a city where we still have attacks on trans men and women and gay-bashing.

Each year thousands and thousands of us come to West Hollywood to celebrate Halloween and Pride and with us also comes our money.  Money that helps keep many of the businesses along Santa Monica Boulevard open.  And let’s be frank, none of those bars and restaurants would survive if they had to rely solely on income received from residents of the city. 

So in that respect many of us are stakeholders in West Hollywood–even if we can’t vote to elect the city’s leadership.

It’s been almost two decades since I’ve lived in West Hollywood. I grew a particular dislike for the city because of the rampant racism and discrimination targeted at Black people at bars and restaurants including the popular Abbey and Mickey’s to name a few.

In 2007, I worked to get a performance in West Hollywood by a white comedian named Charles Knipp cancelled.  Knipp was nationally infamous for his blackface character “Shirley Q. Liquor,” who called herself “Mammy Welfare Queen.” Bars that catered to white gay men and white Pride celebrations would regularly book Knipp seeing nothing at all wrong with a white man dressing in blackface and making fun of Black women and Black culture.

Charles Knipp as Shirley Q. Liquor

For the most part, as a Black lesbian, West Hollywood was not a part of my life in any meaningful way – that is until 2017, when 26-year-old Gemmel Moore died in the Laurel Avenue apartment of Ed Buck.  After that, I found myself in West Hollywood just about every week and sometimes every day.

Buck is a well known and celebrated West Hollywood resident. He is a white gay rights activist, animal rights activist, and political donor with ties to many (but not all) of the members of the West Hollywood City Council.  But Buck is also a crystal meth addict and predator who targeted vulnerable young Black men who came to West Hollywood looking to survive.

Over the next two years additional men would step forward with shocking allegations and receipts regarding the Democratic donor who liked to shoot needles filled with meth into the bodies of Black men. In total, two Black men would die of crystal meth overdoses in Buck’s apartment with a third barely escaping with his life.

The picture became clear early on.  White gay man.  Political donor. Long time resident of West Hollywood.  Wealthy.  Secret life. Racist. Sadistic. A drug addicted predator with a specific fetish for young Black men. And with that I found myself right where I never wanted to be – in the center of West Hollywood’s politics.  Politics that saw four of the five members of the City Council in the pocket of Ed Buck.  

It would take almost three years for us to get Ed Buck arrested, and during that time the spotlight was on West Hollywood, Buck’s safe haven for decades. 

We held vigils, we held protests, we held marches.  We attended City Council meetings demanding action from the same people who took lots of Ed Buck’s money.

We were called monkeys and other racist names.  Neighbors avoided making eye contact with us.  We were told to go back to our side of town.  The sheriff’s were always on hand to watch the Black people whenever we organized anything in West Hollywood calling attention to Ed Buck and his crimes.  The message was clear: the deaths of two Black gay men didn’t matter more than the peace of mind and comfort of the city’s residents, and we were disrupting that peace and making people feel uncomfortable.

And while West Hollywood takes pride in being progressive and liberal, it would become apparent to me that while much had changed since I had last been in the city, a lot hadn’t.

L to r: John Duran and Ed Buck

Councilmember John Duran has served on the West Hollywood Council since 2001.  He was on the Council during the height of the tension between the Black LGBTQ community and the racism they were experiencing when visiting the city.  He was on the council when Charles Knipp was scheduled to perform his Shirley Q. Liquor character in blackface.  He was also on the council when both Gemmel Moore and Timothy Dean died in Ed Buck’s apartment.

Duran has been Buck’s attorney for more than a decade, and has received at least $14,000 in political donations from Buck for his various political campaigns. In fact, of all of the members of the West Hollywood City Council, Duran has benefited the most from Buck’s money–in more ways than one.

So while disheartening, it wasn’t surprising when John Duran tried to intimidate victims of Ed Buck into not coming forward during a council meeting.  He was probably just looking out for his friend and client. Even though a recent New York Times article failed to identify Duran as one of Buck’s close friends and confidants, it has been no secret in West Hollywood the relationship the two share.

In fact, I was so sure that during Ed Buck’s bail hearing, John Duran was at home getting his spare bedroom ready for his friend – afterall he is up for re-election and Buck is still a millionaire several times over.  We’ll never know though since Buck’s bail was denied.

But it isn’t just Duran’s stand for Buck.  

This year John Duran criticized the painting of the transgender flag in the intersection of Santa Monica and San Vicente boulevards. The flag was painted the night before the All Black Lives Matter protest that drew 30,000 participants.

As noted in West Hollywood’s  WEHOville, in 2019, Duran had to step down from the position of mayor after his colleagues on the Council passed a resolution censuring him in response to comments he had made on radio about their sex lives, disparaging comments he had made about an Asian gay man because of his ethnicity, and allegations that he had made unwanted sexual advances on young members of the Gay Men’s Chorus of Los Angeles, which Duran then chaired.  The City of West Hollywood had paid $500,000 to settle a lawsuit filed by Duran’s City Hall deputy accusing him of inappropriate behavior.

Duran described West Hollywood as a “sex-based city” and stated that gay men shouldn’t be held to the same standards as heterosexual men when it comes to their sexual behavior. He also has made it clear that the opinions of anyone who is not a resident of or business owner in West Hollywood do not matter to him.

And if all of that wasn’t enough, the man is touting the endorsement of disgraced former state Democratic Chairman Eric Bauman, who was forced to resign over accusations of sexual misconduct.  Accusations that, just like those involving Duran, have cost hundreds of thousands of dollars to settle. I guess it really is true that birds of a feather flock together.

Rep. Adam Schiff, Ed Buck and former state Democratic Party chair Eric Bauman

Since I’ve gotten back involved with the City of West Hollywood it hasn’t been all bad. I’ve made new friends.  Gotten reacquainted with old ones. When asked to participate in something involving the city I am glad to do it.  I no longer harbor the resentment and dislike for the city I once had. On Saturday, I even spent my Halloween in West Hollywood eating dinner at La Boheme, having drinks at Kitchen 24 and I took a long socially distanced walk in my handmaid costume up and down Santa Monica Boulevard.

I recognize that a lot has changed for the better in West Hollywood.  I know that West Hollywood takes a lot of pride in being a safe space known for its progressive policies and stances.  In 2020, John Duran doesn’t embody or promote that vision -– in fact he actively works to make sure that West Hollywood is only a safe space for men like him –- white and gay.  In a lot of ways, Duran is akin to President Donald Trump in that he can say and do anything he wants and reap no repercussions. That needs to change.

If West Hollywood wants to continue moving forward in the direction of being a city where everyone is welcome regardless of their skin color, zip code, gender, gender identity, or sexual orientation and be taken seriously, then John Duran has to go.

The residents of West Hollywood have the opportunity to send a message that resonates beyond the borders of their city. A message that says you don’t have to live here to be welcome.

On Nov. 3, you have two opportunities to vote for anyone BUT John Duran.  In 2020, West Hollywood shouldn’t have openly racist and anti-trans people serving on their City Council. There’s no other progressive city in America where that would be acceptable. So why should it be in West Hollywood?  It’s time for John Duran to go.

5 2 votes
Article Rating

9 Comments
Newest
Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
hifi5000
hifi5000
24 days ago

I have written in the past on these comment threads regarding racism in West Hollywood.It does exist,but the city is getting better in recognizing their POC visitors who come to the city to enjoy themselves.The city and its businesses need to keep on improving its relations,otherwise gay POC along with their spending dollars will go elsewhere where they will be accepted.

Thank goodness Duran was finally voted out of office.He did a lot of good things for the city,but his past deeds caught up with him.Times has changed,but he didn’t.

Gimmeabreak
Gimmeabreak
27 days ago

IF Jasmyne was called racist names and was told to go back to her side of town it wasn’t by anyone who lives in West Hollywood. I say “IF” because, frankly, I don’t believe it happened. Someone who would deface public property by painting a trans flag without a permit would also throw in that kind of charge to add a little weight to her claims of racism. Her issue with Duran is valid (except she doesn’t mention that he is also a POC, and not white), but beating us up over supposed racism is really a turn-off. I just… Read more »

JF1
JF1
1 month ago

You mention the trans flag painted on the boulevard. This was done WITHOUT a permit. You can’t just go and deface city property – cause you feel just in doing so. So stop. There will always be bigots in the world. But if you see race in ever situation, that’s what a racist does. Stop being a victim. West Hollywood is welcoming to all and any incident to the contrary is not representative of the people that live, work and play here.

Alan Strasburg
Alan Strasburg
29 days ago
Reply to  JF1

Can we get a glorious amen to that bit of truth! It’s tiring to get lumped into one monolithic bucket based on discrete incidents over which I personally have no control and find as objectionable as any decent human being would find them. Sadly, narratives aren’t as convenient when one is forced to treat people as individuals, we’re just “white gay men” who have no unique soul and as a monolith bear the blame for the contemptible actions of a few.

Marco Colantonio
1 month ago

We should applaud Jasmyne Cannick for taking the time to write this op-ed. She cares about our community, how we are perceived, and she endeavors to have a positive impact. That’s what an activist does, and I respect her sincere efforts and advocacy, as do many others in our community, including Mayor Horvath. After I broke the story of Gemmel Moore’s death in WeHo Times, Jasmyne took the lead in the fight for justice and the rights of Gemmel Moore, who lost his voice and life in the apartment of a nefarious WeHo resident and major donor to John Duran.… Read more »

Alan Strasburg
Alan Strasburg
1 month ago

A publicist’s stock in trade is the ability to write a flowery narrative which often is devoid of facts or reasonable conclusions but instead is based on some part platitude, questionable anecdotes and hyperbole, and on treating an entire city as a monolith. That tired narrative is objectively false and demonstrably untrue, but it makes for good business for the publicist. Cannick’s brand is division and she sows it well.

Last edited 1 month ago by Alan Strasburg
Neal Z.
Neal Z.
1 month ago

Ms. Cannick has little room to criticize anyone. Let us not forget that during the same time period where she alleges that actions unfriendly to people of color were taking place, she herself was actively campaigning FOR Proposition 8, the anti-marriage equality initiative put on the ballot and supported by the same folks who are now “Team Trump.” As far as I am aware, at no time in the last 12 years since Cannick actively campaigned for Prop 8 and against LGBT equality has she apologized for her support of this hateful initiative which, once passed, deprived hundreds of thousands… Read more »

Jasmyne Cannick
1 month ago
Reply to  Neal Z.

I am not sure where you are getting your facts from. Trump? I didn’t campaign for Proposition 8 and one simple Google search would tell you that. I just called out the white gay community for its treatment of the Blacks as it related to Prop. 8 and their lack of cultural understanding in their campaign.

West
West
1 month ago

(I tried to be thoughtful in my response to your op-ed) John deserves our criticism for not doing enough while Buck was free. His past political shenanigans are public record. But when you point to the trans flag drama to suggests JD is enemy of POC and trans folk, your argument loses weight. JD has been the City’s strongest leader for the recovery community, the only councilman bold enough to advocate decriminalizing of sex work, and to instigate harm reduction for drug users. John is the only POC in council and the only one to appoint trans people to commissions,… Read more »