WeHo Strikes a Deal with Townscape and Supports 8150 Sunset Project

8150-sunset-blvd

The City of West Hollywood has withdrawn its opposition to the controversial 8150 Sunset Blvd. high-rise retail and residential project after reaching an agreement with Townscape Partners, the project’s developers. Located in Los Angeles on the southwest corner of Sunset and Crescent Heights boulevards, the 8150 project borders West Hollywood and raised concerns due to its height, massing, traffic and sewer impacts.

The withdrawal of the West Hollywood appeal, considered the strongest of five appeals against the project, helped pave the way for the Los Angeles City Council’s five-member Planning and Land Use Management Committee to deny the other four appeals and approve the project on Tuesday. The project now moves to the full 15-member Los Angeles City Council for final approval, possibly as early as next week. Meanwhile, the Land Use committee delayed consideration of granting historic cultural monument status to the 66-year-old Lytton Savings building on the 8150 Sunset site until late November.

West Hollywood Mayor Lauren Meister (right) and Community Development Director Stephanie deWolfe (left)
West Hollywood Mayor Lauren Meister (right) and Community Development Director Stephanie DeWolfe (left)

West Hollywood Mayor Lauren Meister, Community Development Director Stephanie DeWolfe and attorney Beth Collins-Burgard, who represented West Hollywood on this appeal, worked out a handshake agreement with Townscape in the minutes before the Land Use committee heard the 8150 project. Under the terms of the deal, the height of development’s tallest building, once proposed for 234 feet, will be reduced to 178 feet as measured from the lowest point on sloping site. The top floor of that building will have a 10-foot setback on its southern side (which faces West Hollywood) so that the building will appear less tall, and mechanical equipment such as air conditioning compressors will be moved away from the WeHo border.

Additionally, Townscape will give West Hollywood $2 million for traffic improvements. Meister indicated to WEHOville that the city plans to erect bollards at the city’s border along Havenhurst Drive (on the western side of the site) to create a cul-de-sac, similar to the cul-de-sac on Westmount Drive just above the Trader Joes grocery store. That cul-de-sac will prevent traffic leaving the 8150 Sunset project from turning left onto Havenhurst, thus preserving the residential street and thwarting Havenhurst from being used as a cut through street to Fountain Avenue. Townscape will also give the city more than $500,000 for sewer improvements, since the project will connect to West Hollywood’s sewers.

The West Hollywood City Council must still approve this agreement, but Meister reported that the council had discussed what they wanted during a closed session and authorized her and DeWolfe to negotiate it.

“There were certain conditions that we wanted to lock in, that we felt were very important if this project was going to happen, and that was the money for the cul-de-sac and the sewer and reducing the height as much as we thought that would be possible,” Meister told WEHOville.

Meanwhile, staffers for Los Angeles 4th District Councilman David Ryu, who represents the area in which the 8150 Sunset project sits, also negotiated modifications to the project after Ryu wrote a letter demanding changes to the project. When new developments are considered by the L.A. City Council, the council members usually defer to the wishes of their colleague who represents the area, so Townscape, which was initially resistant to changes, was apparently willing to make concessions to get the project approved.

Architect Frank Gehry
Architect Frank Gehry

The number of residential units will be 229, down from 249. Twenty-six of those units will be for very-low income residents and 12 will be “work force” units priced for more moderate income workers. The number of commercial parking spaces was increased per Ryu’s request to 494. The sidewalk along Sunset Boulevard will be widened to 15 feet and Townscape will also give Los Angeles $2 million for traffic improvements.

The project’s 65,000 square feet of commercial use remains unchanged. Plans call for a 25,000 square foot supermarket, a 5,000 square foot bank, 12,000 square feet of retail space and 23,000 square feet of restaurant space. The project, with curved edges and odd angles, is by celebrated architect Frank Gehry, the man who designed the Walt Disney Concert Hall in downtown Los Angeles.

Speaking of the modifications, representatives for Ryu told the committee, “We agree with the modifications. We look forward to continued dialogue with our community as well as the appellants as this moves forward.”

In a statement, Townscape partner Tyler Siegel, said, “These modifications will benefit the community, while ensuring that Frank Gehry’s terrific design provides world-class residences as well as new shopping and eating destinations for our city.”

The 87-year-old Gehry testified before the committee that the site would be “a great entry piece to the Sunset Strip.” Gehry said he agreed to design the project because Townscape shared his values of creating something that would be “special,” have “real architecture” and be “a proud part of the community.”

A standing-room-only crowd filled the L.A. City Council chamber. During over two hours of public comment, many people wearing “Yes 8150 Sunset” stickers, which were provided by Townscape, spoke in favor of the project citing the jobs it would provide and the outstanding architecture. An equal number spoke against it, commenting about the increased traffic congestion and the impact to the neighborhood.

By 7:30 p.m. when public comment was completed, only three of the five committee members were still present (councilmembers Mitch Englander and Marqueece Harris-Dawson both left without explanation during the hearing). There was minimal discussion among the three, who unanimously voted to deny the appeals and approve the project.

Hearing on 8150 Sunset project at L.A. City Hall
Hearing on 8150 Sunset project at L.A. City Hall

“It would be nice if we could still live in the neighborhood that we grew up in, but that does not exist anywhere that I know of in the city,” L.A. Councilmember Gil Cedillo, who serves on the Land Use committee, told the audience. “The fact of the matter is we have a housing crisis, an affordability crisis and a homeless crisis. We have to respond to that. Every single elected [official] in each of the 15 [council] districts has a duty and an obligation to respond to that. So, that’s what this is.”

Councilmember Curren Price questioned whether it was appropriate to approve the project before considering whether to give historic cultural monument status to the Lytton Savings and Loan building located on the northwest corner of the 8150 property. However, city staffers reported that “the historic hearing does not have any bearing on the approval of the project.”

In mid-September the L.A. Cultural Heritage Commission unanimously agreed to grant the landmark status to the Lytton Savings building, designed by noted Southern California architect Kurt Meyer. Now a Chase Bank, the building with its zig-zag folded plate roof, glass walls and interior art work offered a radical architectural departure from traditional bank building when it opened in 1960.

The full L.A. City Council must approve the landmark status before it becomes official. If landmark status is granted, the Lytton Savings building can still be demolished, but there would be several extra legal steps involved before the wrecking ball could hit the building.

Members of Friends of Lytton Savings, the group which petitioned for the building’s landmark status, reported that Townscape Partners indicated they were open to the idea of moving the building. However, a spokesperson for Townscape would not confirm that.

Adrian Scott Fine, director of advocacy for the L.A. Conservancy preservation group, reported that concrete buildings as large as the Lytton building would be especially difficult to move. Similarly, it is not clear where Townscape could move the building to.

“There’s two preservation alternatives on the table that have been deemed viable and meet the project objectives,” Fine told WEHOville. “Why is that not being discussed? Why is the city of Los Angeles ignoring that path forward that allows preservation and new development to happen at the same time? Personal preferences should not override state law or the heritage of Los Angeles.”

Gehry seemed uninterested in adapting his designs to be compatible with the mid-century modern Lytton Savings building. Gehry explained to the committee that the construction crane needed to erect the project’s two towers had to be placed in the location of the Lytton building.

“Unfortunately, the bank building is in a precarious position to enable craning a proper project on the site,” Gehry said.

West Hollywood resident Rory Barish, who spearheaded the Save Sunset Blvd. group to oppose the project, believes the committee was blinded by Gehry’s status as a world-renowned architect.

“They’re viewing Gehry as a god. That’s why he was here today,” said Barish, who lives on Havenhurst adjacent to the project. “That’s why Townscape hired him, to help get this approved.”

After the hearing, Steven Luftman, who helped found the Friends of Lytton Savings group, commented to WEHOville, “This could be an amazing opportunity to have two of the most significant architects of Los Angeles together in one project. I don’t know what it is that’s keeping it from happening. I find it terribly sad that one architect would want to erase another’s work.”


newest oldest
Notify of
Will
Guest
Will

This investigative/LA Times article pretty much explains what goes on with every illegal zone changing obscene, oversized controversial, heatedly opposed project.. http://www.latimes.com/projects/la-me-seabreeze/ More reason to vote for The Neighborhood Integrity Initiative in March and vote garcetti out. The project in article is not the only one garcetti’s planning commission rejected that garcetti rejected their decision and made sure projects went through anyway.. campaign contributions and other funding via laundering, as mentioned in article, to city politicos, are business as usual to assure they get approved. garcetti rescinds his own planning commission’s votes, because deals ($$$$) have been cut with developers… Read more »

Development Woes
Guest
Development Woes

& Mike Dolan: Two of the architects that designed buildings in immediate proximity to 8150 Sunset have nearly every building designed recognized as a landmark. Some have multiply designations ….National, State and Local. The Zweibel’s known for their exquisite courtyard buildings and Leland Bryant whose study of the great chateaux of the Loire Valley and a riff on Art Deco inspired by the Paris Exposition resulted in countless elegant buildings in West Hollywood, Hollywood and Los Angeles. This seems of no material consideration to the disrupter team of Townscape & Gehry. One can never project their place in the annals… Read more »

Development Woes
Guest
Development Woes

@ Steve Martin: Being a vocal critic about Townscape’s Beverly Blvd. project and collapsing in the home stretch proved that one has no real heart and substance. When an individual’s “prized commitments” were represented as development and transportation issues this indicates a major fail. Euphemistic campaign wishes and dreams do not automatically translate into action especially when negotiation is clearly beyond one’s scope. Blind Sided in the home stretch with no concept of all the moving parts.

Development Woes
Guest
Development Woes

@ Mike Dolan: BTW FOG has already left an imprint on Sunset Blvd. Have you missed it?

Mike Dolan
Guest
Mike Dolan

@Development Woes, your statement, “An architect sensitive to the surrounding area both LA and WH would easily have been able to act upon inspiration from the Lytton Savings Bank and design an interesting and respectful project.” Is representative of the time. I would not ever compare personally Lytton Savings Band and Kurt Meyer’s to Frank Gehry. Both highly respected for their contributions; Meyer’s, in my opinion, does not stand the test of time. Like Frank Lloyd Wright and Gehry possess that quality. However, I’m sure Meyer’s designs were a welcome, new and creative architectural direction that was quite different at… Read more »

Development Woes
Guest
Development Woes

Actually, now that I commented on bloated sensibilities, I recall that is the unfortunate affliction of Townscape’s Beverly Blvd project.

Time to build interesting projects in a straightforward manner. Too simple? Some folks seem to love drama and posturing. That burns up too much time and $$$$$.

Development Woes
Guest
Development Woes

This was not a project that required Frank Grhry or any architect in the so called “upper echelons”. An architect sensitive to the surrounding area both LA and WH would easily have been able to act upon inspiration from the Lytton Savings Bank and design an interesting and respectful project . Although Kurt Meyers design might not be my personal fave I recognize his excellence and representation of an important era and rightful place in the architectural language and fabric of LA. The problem here was a development team with a bloated sense of reality in both their behavior and… Read more »

Mike Dolan
Guest
Mike Dolan

Development happens because the economy is good and that always benefits the people. Yes, I agree, the construction during the improvement is a nuisance. All developments’ have a beginning and end. Always the people are directly or indirectly the beneficiary and impacted during development. This has always been the reality in a high density area. The people must spotlight deficiencies or additions that improve the development before construction to make the development optimum. The organic nature of a healthy economy and market forces will always prevail even if an individual would like to see no growth, low growth or influence… Read more »

SaveWeho
Guest
SaveWeho

Yes…there were some missed opportunities here. I agree with Todd. Gehry isn’t the only starchitect. I’m also EXTREMELY disappointed in the number of low income units. It should be at minimum 20-30%. But there is something else important with the low-income units. I’m discovering many dont include parking for those designated units. They assume the low income folks are too poor to own vehicles and will us public transportation. We also need to mandate that parking is required for EACH unit regardless of classification. I get so disgusted with whoever is running the show. They make backhanded deals to cut… Read more »

Todd Bianco
Guest

A couple of things. First, Frank Gehry isn’t the only talented architect in Los Angeles. How about Zoltan Pali? There are many others who would kill for a chance to make a landmark project. I think Townscape is simply using Gehry’s name to get an approval for a project that he may not end up designing. No one wants just another “modern” box with little visual interest. I’d rather have another PDC Red Building than another Avalon (Movietown Plaza) rabbit warren. Second, there is always inconvenience, noise and other negative factors that go along with a major construction project. That’s… Read more »

Mike Dolan
Guest
Mike Dolan

Thank you Andrew Macpherson. I too am excited to see the final masterpiece, by Gehry, at 8150 Sunset Blvd. I too, agree with Josh Kurpies, on the relative size of this project and the lack to achieve a higher % of affordable units. What happened to this element in “Weho Strikes a Deal…” I’m puzzled with Councilmember Ryu strong recommendation to save the bank building but not to increase affordable units to at least 30%. I don’t understand the priorities of this deal either from the City of Los Angeles nor the City of West Hollywood and its-DEAL??? I ask… Read more »

Andrew Macpherson
Guest

I would vigorously disagree with Todd. Having devoted years to fighting the original hideous cookie-cutter design as one of the founders of the neighborhood group Save Sunset Boulevard, I think a ‘starchitect’ is exactly what was needed. Los Angeles is putting up so many hideous oversized steel framed boxes with no imagination that it is loosing it soul. As the entertainment capital of the world our city should and could rival Hong Kong, Dubai and Shanghai in its expressions of architectural imagination and excellence. I live by, and directly overlook the site, which is why I supported the community fight… Read more »